Blog
Best dunning software for subscription apps
Dunning software compared: the main types of tool, what each one does with a failed renewal, and which suits an app at volume.
Published:
·
9 min read

Dunning software recovers subscription payments that fail. It retries the card, updates details that have changed, and asks the customer to fix what it can’t. Done well, the customer barely notices. Done badly, you lose a subscriber who never meant to leave.
This page is about card renewals for subscription businesses. If you’re chasing unpaid B2B invoices, you want accounts receivable software, and most of what follows won’t apply.
We should declare an interest. OpenByte sells dunning as part of its billing, payments and support platform. We’ll say what the other tools do well, and where we think the usual approach runs out at scale.
The short version
What it is: software that recovers failed subscription payments.
What it does: retries cards, updates expired details and prompts customers to fix their payment method.
What it isn’t: a fix for customers who choose to cancel.
Who it suits: any subscription business where failed renewals cost more than the software.
What is dunning software?
Dunning software is a tool that recovers failed recurring payments. It decides when to retry a declined card, keeps card details up to date, and contacts the customer when a retry won’t work. Most subscription billing platforms include basic dunning, and specialist tools add more on top.
The difference between tools is mostly in three places: how they decide when to retry, what they do once retries stop working, and how many payment providers they can try. The table shows the main types.
Type | What it does | Examples | When a subscription app needs it |
|---|---|---|---|
Built into your billing platform | Retries on a schedule or with a model, plus failed-payment emails | Stripe Billing, Recurly, Chargebee | Always. It’s the baseline |
Recovery add-on | Adds smarter emails, SMS, in-app prompts and card-update pages on top of your billing | Churn Buster, Churnkey, Baremetrics Recover, FlyCode | When the built-in emails aren’t getting cards updated |
Human outreach | People contact customers whose payments failed | Gravy | For high-value customers worth a personal touch |
Payment orchestration with dunning | Retries a declined renewal on a different payment provider | OpenByte, Recurly All-Access | When one provider’s declines, or its bad days, are costing real money |
The last row is where we come in, and where most lists stop. Retrying the same card on the same provider is fine at a few hundred renewals. At a few hundred thousand, a provider having a bad morning turns into a bad month, and no email sequence fixes that.
Our view. Before buying a recovery tool, find out why your renewals fail. Split last month’s declines into soft and hard. Retries and emails help with soft declines. Hard declines need the customer, and outages need a second provider.
Why subscription renewals fail
Most failed renewals fall into three groups, and each needs a different fix.
Soft declines. The bank says no for now: insufficient funds, a fraud check, a temporary limit. A retry at the right moment often works.
Hard declines. The card is closed, reported stolen or simply wrong. Retrying the same card won’t help, so you need the customer, or an updated card from the networks.
Provider trouble. The bank was fine, but your payment provider wasn’t: an outage, a timeout, a bad routing day. Only a second provider fixes that.
Dunning software is very good at the first group, decent at the second, and mostly helpless with the third. Our guide to why payment retries fail at scale goes deeper, and involuntary vs voluntary churn explains what failed renewals do to your churn numbers.
Best dunning software compared
The table covers the tools a subscription business is most likely to shortlist. Pricing models vary more than features do, so that column matters most. Everything comes from each company’s own site, checked on 17 November 2026.
Tool | Type | Works with | How it prices |
|---|---|---|---|
Stripe Billing | Built into billing | Stripe only | Included in Billing’s 0.7% of billing volume |
Recurly | Built into billing | Recurly, with 20+ gateways | Starter $249 a month plus 0.9%. Intelligent Retries need a higher plan |
Chargebee | Built into billing | Chargebee. Revive on Stripe and Braintree only | Included in Billing plans from 0.65% or 0.80% |
Churn Buster | Recovery add-on | Stripe, Braintree, Recurly, Shopify, Recharge and others | From $269 a month, flat |
Churnkey | Recovery add-on | Stripe, Chargebee, Braintree, Paddle, Maxio | From $250 a month, priced by monthly churn volume |
Baremetrics Recover | Recovery add-on | Stripe, Braintree, Recurly. Chargebee in part | $129 a month on top of a Baremetrics plan |
FlyCode | Recovery add-on | Stripe and Shopify apps, plus an API | A share of revenue recovered above a baseline. Rate not published |
Gravy | Human outreach | Not stated | Flat fee after an audit. Not published |
Paddle Retain | Built into a merchant of record | Paddle Billing | No separate price |
OpenByte | Orchestration with dunning | Several payment providers at once | Custom, based on scale and scope |
Built in: Stripe, Recurly and Chargebee
Start here, because you’re probably already paying for it. Stripe’s Smart Retries are on by default and make up to eight retries within two weeks. Recurly’s retries stop at 20 attempts or 60 days, and its machine-learning retries need a plan above Starter. Chargebee’s Revive works only with Stripe and Braintree.
All three are reasonable. The question is whether yours is switched on and tuned, which is a surprisingly common gap. Our dunning strategy playbook covers what tuned looks like.
Recovery add-ons: Churn Buster, Churnkey, Baremetrics Recover and FlyCode
These sit on top of your billing and do the customer-facing work better: emails from your own domain, SMS, in-app prompts and card-update pages that don’t need a login. Baremetrics Recover has no retry schedule of its own, and leaves retries to your processor.
Pricing is where they differ. Churn Buster charges a flat fee, which its own FAQ puts at about 0.1% of monthly recurring revenue. FlyCode takes a share of what it recovers above a baseline. That’s fair in principle, but the baseline is everything, so agree how it’s measured before you sign.
Human outreach: Gravy
Gravy’s team contacts customers by text and email over 30 days. That’s a lot of attention per failed payment, which suits high-value subscriptions. On a $12.99 monthly plan, the arithmetic is harder to make work.
Merchant of record: Paddle Retain
Retain comes with Paddle Billing at no separate price. If you already sell through Paddle, use it. It isn’t a reason to move to Paddle on its own.
Our view. Pick an add-on for the problem you can see in your data. If customers aren’t updating cards, buy better outreach. If retries are failing on soft declines, tune the retry logic first. Neither fixes a provider having a bad day.
Where OpenByte fits
OpenByte includes dunning as part of its billing, payments and support platform. Retries are timed to why the payment failed, cards are updated automatically, and it knows when to stop retrying and ask the customer instead. Our dunning management page has the detail.
The difference from the tools above is the third group of failures. OpenByte’s payment orchestration can retry a declined renewal on a different provider, so one provider’s bad morning doesn’t become your bad month. Recurly’s All-Access plan does something similar, from $1 million of monthly billing volume.
That matters most for businesses renewing hundreds of thousands of customers a month. Below that, a built-in tool plus a good add-on is usually enough. Our backup payment gateway page explains the failover side.
What dunning software costs at volume
Four pricing models turn up, and they behave very differently as you grow.
Pricing model | Example | What happens as you grow |
|---|---|---|
Share of billing volume | Stripe Billing, Recurly, Chargebee | Dunning is bundled, so you pay for it whether it’s good or not |
Flat monthly fee | Churn Buster, Baremetrics Recover | Gets cheaper per renewal as volume rises |
Priced by churn volume | Churnkey | Rises with failed payments, so falls as you fix the causes |
Share of recovered revenue | FlyCode | Costs nothing if it recovers nothing, but depends on the baseline |
Picture an app renewing $5 million of subscriptions a month. A flat-fee tool costs the same whether you renew $500,000 or $5 million. A share of recovered revenue scales with your failures, which is fine until someone has to agree what would have been recovered anyway.
Our view. At volume, flat fees tend to win, and outcome-based pricing needs a baseline both sides can measure. Ask every vendor to show their maths on your last three months of failed payments.
How to choose dunning software
These are the questions we’d put to every vendor on a shortlist.
Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
Does it run its own retries, or rely on your processor’s? | Some add-ons only send messages |
Does it treat soft and hard declines differently? | Retrying a closed card wastes attempts and annoys banks |
Which billing systems and processors does it support? | Several only work fully with Stripe and Braintree |
Can customers update a card without logging in? | Every extra step loses customers |
Can it retry on a different payment provider? | The only fix for provider outages |
How is the price worked out at your volume? | Flat, per failure and per recovery behave very differently |
Frequently asked questions
What is dunning software?
Dunning software recovers failed subscription payments. It retries declined cards at better times, updates expired card details and contacts customers who need to fix their payment method. Most billing platforms include basic dunning, and specialist tools add smarter outreach and retries on top.
What is the best dunning software?
It depends on your billing system and your failures. Stripe, Recurly and Chargebee include dunning. Churn Buster, Churnkey and Baremetrics Recover add better outreach. For businesses renewing hundreds of thousands of customers, OpenByte adds retries across more than one payment provider.
What is a dunning management system?
A dunning management system is software that runs the whole recovery process for failed recurring payments: retry timing, card updates, customer emails or texts, and when to stop. It can be part of a billing platform or a separate tool that connects to one.
How much does dunning software cost?
Prices checked in November 2026: Churn Buster starts at $269 a month, Churnkey at $250 a month billed yearly, and Baremetrics Recover adds $129 a month to a Baremetrics plan. FlyCode charges a share of recovered revenue. Stripe, Recurly and Chargebee bundle dunning into billing fees.
Does Stripe have dunning?
Yes. Stripe Billing includes Smart Retries, which are on by default and make up to eight retries within two weeks, plus failed-payment and card-expiry emails. According to Stripe’s docs, hard declines aren’t retried automatically. It works only for payments that run through Stripe.
Do I need dunning software if my billing platform already has dunning?
Not always. Start by checking the built-in tools are switched on and tuned. Add a specialist tool when customers aren’t updating cards, or when you can see recoverable failures slipping through. Neither will fix outages at your payment provider.
What’s the difference between a soft and a hard decline?
A soft decline is temporary, such as insufficient funds or a fraud check, and a later retry often works. A hard decline is permanent, such as a closed or stolen card, so retrying the same card won’t help. Good dunning software treats the two differently.
How many times should you retry a failed payment?
It depends on the decline. Stripe’s default is up to eight retries in two weeks, and Recurly stops at 20 attempts or 60 days. The card networks also limit retries on the same card, so check the current rules with your acquirer before setting your own.
What is the difference between dunning and accounts receivable software?
Dunning software recovers failed card payments on subscriptions, usually automatically. Accounts receivable software chases unpaid invoices from business customers, often with reminders and collections workflows. If you bill consumers by card each month, you want dunning software.
Key takeaways
Dunning software recovers failed renewals by retrying cards, updating details and prompting customers.
Renewals fail for three reasons: soft declines, hard declines and provider trouble. Dunning handles the first two.
Check your billing platform’s built-in dunning is switched on and tuned before buying anything.
Pricing models differ more than features do. At volume, flat fees tend to beat a share of recovered revenue.
Only retrying on a second payment provider fixes provider outages.
Pull last month’s failed renewals and sort them into soft declines, hard declines and provider errors. The biggest group tells you what to buy.
Keep reading

Chargeback management software: a buyer’s guide for subscription apps
Chargeback management software explained, sorted by type, and priced at the volumes subscription apps actually run.

Involuntary churn vs voluntary churn: what's the difference, and how to reduce it
Involuntary churn explained for subscription businesses: what it is, how it differs from voluntary churn, what causes it, and how to reduce it without breaking the card networks’ rules.

Payment failure: why subscription payments fail, decline codes, and how to reduce failed payments
Payment failure explained for subscription businesses: why renewals fail, what decline codes mean, soft vs hard declines, and how to reduce failed payments within the card network rules.

